Virginia Key Redevelopment: Your Questions and Concerns Answered
After our first Virginia Key episode, we got flooded with questions and concerns from viewers — so we brought the team back to answer every single one. David Fi...
Sobre este episodio
They also reveal that the current marina is not even a certified clean marina and has been polluting the bay, that the current operator has sued the city three times, and that the city has lost an estimated $15-20 million from delays in this process. Plus a surprise visit from Monty Trainer himself, who shares his blessing for the project and drops some legendary Miami history.
City of Miami residents vote November 3rd.
A Day in Miami Website:
https://adayinmiami.com/
Manny Alfonso:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/mannyalfonso8/
Kiko Suarez:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/querikoconkiko/
Eduardo Moya:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/mr_moya/
Follow Us! - A Day in Miami:
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/adayinmiami/
Listen on Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/show/20WEys6jxiliBCLoo9iSID
________________________
Produced by: Ben Schwede
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/benthecreatorrr/
0:00 Intro
3:16 Introducing the Guests
4:20 Why They Wanted to Preserve Monty’s
6:16 Will Gramps Getaway Be Preserved in Their New Project?
7:40 Dredging and Mega Yachts?
9:45 First Won Bid in 2017
12:58 Why It Was Rejected Later by the Commission
13:55 2nd Request For Proposal (RFP)
16:37 Shady Process and Current Operator Losing the Bid Twice
19:00 The Process Summed Up
19:56 Current Operator Proposed Bigger Scale Project
21:22 Environment Concerns
23:50 Development on Virginia Key Will Happen Anyways
25:58 Benefits of the Deal to the City
28:29 Current Operator Getting Sued by the City
31:02 Are They Out-of-State Private Equity Bros?
32:33 How He Feels About the Comments
35:06 How Independent Court Decided that City Commission Was Wrong
37:27 Why They Didn’t Give Up Even After City Commission’s Shady Practices
39:18 Monty Joining the Show
39:48 Monty’s Working Since 1969
40:36 Hurricane Andrew
42:03 Relationship with Suntex Marinas
46:23 Monty Being on Board of Virginia Key
46:59 Why Monty Believes in Their Saving the Virginia Key Project
49:18 Events on Monty’s Boat and Buying Bayfront Park
53:32 Manny Summing Up the Save Virginia Key Process
56:20 Monty’s Legacy
57:15 Monty’s Started Outdoor Dining in Miami
58:40 Outro
Okay,
we good.
We're good.
Sure.
We're good.
Where where where are we live today here?
This is a legendary location.
This is a legendary location. Legendary location. Legendary place.
I wish I wish we did more interviews like this outside hanging out. Not not in the office, you know.
Listen, if I mean my my my contract does not have anything of outdoor locations because of the heat, but you know, there could always be a little provision.
But your hair is looking good.
No, no, it's great. No, I had to take away the fan. people thought I was Beyonce with the with the fan going on. Listen, you know, we're we're we're we're doing this another podcast because I think it's very important for us to go ahead and and
yeah, I think uh to clear things up basis again,
there's a lot of questions in the comments that people have and I think we're going to be here to clear up those exact questions that people are asking and and wondering, you know.
Yeah.
Can But before we start, can I say that we are we keep on saying we're in the legendary place, but we haven't mentioned the place.
Oh, yeah. We we we are the legend legendary Monty Monty's in the Grove. Whoever does not have a Monty's in the Grove story has not lived in Miami. I always say I'm an 80s guy. The best time, the best era.
What was your craziest story here?
Oh god. I This is what is this RX? What? What show is this?
This is whatever we want to be. We can rate it whatever we want. Double R if we have to. I mean this is there's there's such great times. I can tell you people that uh you know became boyfriend girlfriend here. People that from here became got married. I mean this was a place that it still is. Let's let's be clear still is. I mean I just want to tell you about my experiences and and the fact of even knowing Monty you know was even even that much
I heard he would throw like some pretty nice boat parties.
He he Monty's was Monty to this day is you know I don't know. Oh, I mean we're going to have to do a bronze statue.
Yeah.
You know that whole uh that whole statue that we have in in in what what is it? The football stadium.
American Airlines Arena. Well, we have Don Shula. We have Wade.
Well, but Wade does not look like Wade.
So, that's another that's another podcast.
But he gave it his approval. He said, you know what? I don't know what happened there.
It's an artistic version of me. He said,
so listen, being that said, you know, uh we wanted to clarify. What do we want to clarify? We want to do a whole clarification.
Yeah. So, you know, we got our we got our our our guys here back for uh save Virginia Key. All right. Uh everybody knows the um the November 3rd election has uh a question on it and whether or not you want to beautify and make Virginia Key better than what it is right now. Uh they've been at this for close to 10 years. Um, as a as a business owner ourselves, um, I I kind of understand your point of view and what you guys have gone through. Uh, and I think it's important for the viewers to kind of, you know, see past the narrative that's being put out there and really understand the nuances of how we got here. You know, something that should have been relatively simple and straightforward has become extremely complex and political. It
Well, it's called City of Miami politics, baby. City of Miami politics.
That's what we always hear and you guys now see it. You're living it. You're breathing it. And you're going to vote on it on true City of Miami politics fashion.
Yeah.
So, we got our guys here. Introduce
David. Bobby.
You know, every time I say Bobby, I feel like saying Rick and Bobby. [laughter]
My My name is David Filler. I'm the chief development officer for Suntax Marinas. Um, and we currently, um, own and operate the marina where we are today and the Monty's restaurant that we're sitting in right now.
And the one also in on on on Beach Marina, but we do we don't operate that restaurant.
Gotcha. Gotcha.
But we do we do operate this one. Um, and we've partnered with Monty to preserve his legacy. Right now, we're investing um over a million dollars in um refurbishing and revitalizing Monty's um with new bathrooms, new tables and chairs, new bar to put uh brand new tiki huts. Yeah. To make it the to continue Monty's legacy and make it the best dining experience in in Miami. stick sticking on that because before we get into this whole thing of the this whole ballot thing again, what what was it that that got you guys say we want to we want to continue the Montas? I think it's so important, you know, like a staple like this, you know, because a lot of companies come and like to take over places and now call it, you know, whatever. Bobby's, you know what I'm saying?
Ricky Bobbies. Ricky Bobbies, you know, on the bay,
which probably would have be a bad idea, but
but listen, but the fact of when you guys decided you've been I want you guys to How long have you been here already?
What was the key factor saying we got to continue the the the the Monty Trainer idea of
Well, Mont Monty is a legend. Yes.
And it's the heart and soul of Miami.
Yes.
And we have wanted to continue that legacy um by improving it. Um, we've we've come up with some we've kept the menu primarily the same as it was for 50 years. Um, we've added some new things, um, some more healthy choices to give people some options while still keeping the staples. But there is no better location and name than Monty's in the city of Miami. It's the heart and soul of Coconut Grove.
Having gone to school at University of Miami and every Thursday night Yeah. ending up here. I think it it's essential
essential to keep
There must be some stories here, too.
Yeah, I have my own stories. But but no, having namesakes like this preserved.
Yeah.
You know, preserving this because so much of Miami is changing and some for the good, some for the bad. But this is, you know, preserving names like this and keeping restaurants like this alive is what we need to do.
Yeah. That that's that's important. And I think part of this whole thing of what you guys are are proposing which we're going to get into now is importance of people know the background of the people that are involved.
You know what I'm saying? And the fact of you guys being you know a company that came in to Monty's here and the Monty's over there on the beach also and preserving what it was I think is a huge importance. So with that Ed what what what you know what are the what are the biggest concerns that everybody has out there? What what are the concerns? Let's see if we can get these guys to clarify all these concerns.
I think it'll be important. I think uh the number one concern that we see out there is uh the Gramps situation, right? Uh everybody likes Gramps, you know, like the job. Uh unfortunately, I you know, he had a a situation in his previous location. They were moved then to the Virginia Key and Becker Marina. Um and people, you know, want to know is Grahams going to stay, you know, in this new project that you guys have going on. So, do you want to kind of clarify that and where your position where that is and and you know, how do you feel about that?
Yeah. So, I think it we're very clear about it. Um, we want to preserve Gramps. We want Gramps to stay. We've sent a letter to that extent to Gramps. I've also spoken to the lawyer and the owner of Gramps that we want them to stay. Our bid in 2017 was to preserve that building and keep it in place and keep the restaurant that was there at the time which was Whiskey Joe's before Gramps in place and operating and just upgrade it, renovate it like we're doing Monty's and create, you know, nicer restrooms, nicer opportunities, but keep Gramps. We That's what we want to do.
Yeah. So, a better overall experience. And I think that's important for people to know. So, Gramps is going to be saved. Okay.
We're not getting rid of Gramps.
We're not getting rid of Grams. you know, I I mean,
that's that's part of the misinformation.
So, that that that's one of the the the most important ones that I've seen. Uh the other situation that I've seen or or comments that people are concerned about, not that I see, but people are concerned about is is there going to be any dredging going on in the new development and I see a lot of this is going to be built for mega yachts. You know, it's all mega yachts are going to be there now. It stops being for the regular people, the regular public. It's gonna be high-end retail, high-end restaurants. So to to answer that, no. No dredging. The boats the boat sizes are there today will be there tomorrow.
You know, that is not going to happen. We're not going to just make this a mega marina. That's not the case at all. Never was never was part of our drawings when we bid on the project. So the size of boats that are there today will be the same tomorrow.
Damn, Manny was I just put up a
Can you imagine that 220 I was thinking about for the love of God. Damn, helipad as well. But any you know, it won't fit. it won't fit to even and to even complement what what Bobby said. Um it's in our proposal that's a public document. 90 90% of the marina is for boats around 40 ft and lower. So it's it's all it's all there. It's broken down. The the if since we're not dredging, it can't accommodate mega yachts the marina. So there's no mega yachts being proposed, nor were they in our drawings either.
Okay. Yeah. Yeah. You go on Google Earth and look, the same size boat that's there today is the same one in our drawing that we turned in 2017.
Got and and so before we continue with that, I think that you know when when we're talking, I think that our viewers because we've gotten a couple of people which, you know, again, we welcome, let me just be very very clear, we welcome every good, bad comment. We we love it. Send it our way. That's that's go ahead. It's it's it's not an issue, you know, and and thank you to a lot of people that don't even live in in the Miami area, you know. I'm I'm glad a lot of people are getting involved from Fort Lauderdale and from I don't know, Palm Beach and I don't know, I saw some people even from I think from California, but that's besides the point. But we welcome the comments. Anyway, my biggest thing is I would like you guys to please clarify because maybe some people are confused. What has been the process of you guys bidding for this property? Which could we clarify? Is this a private property or is it who who owns this?
The city of Miami. The people of Miami.
So, this is owned by the the the taxpayers
by taxpayers. That that's who's being protected in this process.
So, when did you guys when did this come about? when when was this more or less come out to bid and and take us through the process so everybody can understand
how you guys are here?
I'm I'm assuming the commission came together and said we're putting out an RFP for a project uh Rickenbacher Marina.
Correct.
Okay.
Correct. They combined both the city facility there and Rickenbacher
as part of that RFP.
Okay.
And and that came out that was the first one that came out and we went in front of again
I'm sorry Bobby when was that more or less?
2017.
Okay. 2017.
Okay. And so we went out, we put together a beautiful proposal, beautiful drawing, um, you know, access on the waterfront so people can go walk again from Marine Stadium down to Rusty Pelican.
Correct.
And and and really a facility for all. So not just you have a boat here, you're going to utilize the facility. You want to come here and have access to the waterfront, you want to rent a paddle board, you want to rent a kayak or whatever that is, um, you can come to this facility. And that was part of our design, okay, in 2017. So, we went in front of an independent uh seven I think it's seven person party um bunch of different professionals and we're awarded the bid or won won the process.
When you say independent, you have no idea who those people are.
You know who's on the selection committee, but it was picked by the city of Miami. They they so they picked it. Very important because that's how you know it's not something you guys hire or the other people are there hired. Is it independent people that the city which is what is it? Is it is it the city and approved by the city commissioners of this independent board?
So there's a there's a process for the selection of an independent selection committee. Correct. The city the city uh staff andor commission approves in the first round approves it. They we none of the potential proposers can have any communications with the selection committee. It's like a cone of silence is what they call it.
So you submit and you present. The only time that you communicate with them is during the presentation period when you give both you give a written proposal and then you go present that proposal in front of the selection committee which we did twice and one twice. Okay. the the first time uh after the first bid was thrown out, they the city commission claimed
I'm sorry, David, I don't want to interrupt you, brother, but it's very important because I know how our viewers are. So, you know, we got to really understand that.
Okay.
The first time you guys won this.
Yeah.
Okay.
Yeah. Who bidded it on that? Who was it? You and
who bid it on that?
You you there was three biders, but I wouldn't want to break it down because we were technically against each other at that time.
All right. Okay. But at the end of the day,
Yeah.
it the fair process won.
Yes. Okay.
Yeah. So then after that happens, you you
you're getting ready.
What happened? Like if if if I feel like if you know we go out for bids too. So when we go out for bid and we won the bid, I mean, okay, we're good. We won the bid. What's what's the next step? So what happened?
So after the first round of bidding,
correct?
The the commission elected to throw out all bids. Um the the commission felt that there weren't enough experts, marine experts on the selection committee. Okay. So, here we go.
So, here we go.
Here we go. Right. Right.
So, so there weren't enough marine experts.
Okay. So, which which is the people that they brought in,
right? The people they
So, hey, we picked these people. Sorry, you won. We didn't feel we picked enough marine experts here.
We didn't like the result.
We didn't like the result. So, we didn't like the results that came in of the people that they hired to be the independent panel to choose uh a person to do the marina.
Yeah. And not for nothing, me as a business owner, I would be livid if something like that happened. But go for it.
How about how about when they take your design from the first one and make it the scope of the second RFP?
Oh, well, I didn't know that.
Right. So, so then go so then you hit the second RFP.
So, so thank you for including that, Bobby.
Yeah. So, go ahead, David. They as the sec as part of the second RFP, the commission demanded or required that there'll be there's more marine experts. So each commissioner I think is the way it worked got to make sure that they would pick one marinebased expert as part of their selection committee and they they also I believe participated in the process. So again, it was a committee full of experts, right? An independent committee,
full of experts, right, that had knowledge, industry knowledge as to what to look for in a marina presentation,
right? Nice. Right. So, and currently that's at the same that commission already changed more or less, right, of commissioners from then to now, maybe
three times. Okay.
So then, so you went for the second RFP. They use your drawings of the first RFP as the example of what they're looking for,
of what they want. Okay. Yeah.
So then what happened there?
Did they ask for permission for that? didn't have to
didn't have to. So, so we won that selection committee voted us as the number one proposal.
Okay. So, let's let's stop there because, you know, I know everybody's out there very busy. So, we're going to rewind it again. So, the this the commission again now went each of them picked out their own, you know, biology or or or water marine expert gurus. They brought them and then they put a second bid out.
Correct.
Yep. And they put a criteria.
Okay. What was that criteria?
Financial capability, past projects.
Okay.
You know, there's a bunch of things.
Each commissioner put criteria in the RFP.
In the RFP. Got you.
The criteria. Okay.
So, you you would get points in each category. So, you could you would get a a scoring methodology was utilized to determine points. So, one of them was financial capability. Okay.
Another one was you know marina experience. Okay. Okay. Another one was development with projects and I may be a little off on some of the categories but these are the concepts development experience in building or redoing a marina of this size and scale.
Okay.
Right. Um so there was I believe four or five different
criteria that each criteria got judged and ranked and they had to put point a point system. Okay.
You know and they would rank it like 1 to 20 or 1 to 25
and you guys won that process as well. who won that independent selection committee.
I got another question and I may be naive with this.
The the people that are currently there now, were they also part of the the process, did they did they bid on that?
Yes.
Yes. They lost twice. They lost.
So they lost. So the people that are there now lost twice. Correct.
Okay. And and did those people that are there now, have they ever been in the bidding process or were they just put there by by by the commissioner? When what when was that? You know, do we know that 40 years ago how they got it?
Yeah. So after they threw out all bids when after winning it a second time. Correct.
After they threw out all bids, there was a proposal that was put forth to the commission to allow for an unsolicited bid.
Uhhuh.
That did not go through the proper process to go to referendum.
Okay. So to make that that's to make that clear to the people
when you talk about an unsolicited bid where you're telling is the owners of the property which is not the city commission
correct
it's the city residents and the taxpayers you're the people you're telling the people that the commissioners
proposed because I want to be very clear about that you know the who proposed to take this to a non-bidding thing the the commission voted on this
yes correct right okay it'd be interesting I would love to go back to the files to see who who proposed Yeah. Do
we know who proposed that?
I think it was Ken Russell.
Ken Russell. Yeah.
Yeah. Ken Russell was a leader on this. And and and what we've come to see is every time they didn't get the result that they wanted,
Yeah.
they came up with a different process.
Okay.
So, as Eddie said a little while ago,
do you imagine now being a regular Joemo? you know that you're, you know, this guy, you have a plumbing company, HVAC work, and you say, "Wow, I have an opportunity to bid for something in a city like a, you know, a million dollar contract, and all of a sudden you're happy." And you you worked with your family, your kids to come up with a number, and all of a sudden you bid it, you want it, but then h it's not the guy, that's not him, or we don't like that guy. Oh, they found something to throw away those bids, you know? So that means like the little the little guy can get always like, you know, stomped on if you don't if you don't know how to play with the with the big dogs.
Yeah. The crazy part about this whole thing is
we won the process and all we've been trying to do is get to the people to vote on this.
Yeah.
Get to the people. It's taken eight years and litigation for seven of them to get to
So to be clear, sir,
one RFP number one, you guys faced first place. City commission came in, new one came in. We don't like it. We need better marine experts.
We're doing number two. Got new marine experts. You won RFP number two,
we're good. We're good to go. Nope. We're not good to go. City commission voted to take it to the people for a no bid contract to be allowed to happen with the current operator would be the one that stays in operation of the property and he moves forward with no bid.
Right. The good the good people of the city of Miami voted no.
The good people of the city of Miami, which is, you know, they're smart. They said, "I'm not gonna fall for this.
You want no bid?" So then, okay, no bid fails. You're thinking, "We're good to go now to the voters." No. They got this caught up in litigation and now you're here x amount of years later. Finally, a judge said the city was in the wrong and the city has to put it to the voters. And that's what they're voting on November 3rd.
Correct.
That's crazy to me.
Yeah. And and what's what's even more interesting is so the current operator Abad Melwani when he ran his own referendum put forth a project of equal or greater scale than what we're proposing now
and and Ken Russell was behind that. And so everything that we're suggesting, he went to the the uh the public with in his own referendum, which he's now crying a foul for now that's going to effectively hurt the environment. He ran the same campaign to create a project of equal or greater value because his I believe investment at the time was 125 million, right? So that was of equal or greater scale. And what what was also interesting was that the Miami Herald caught wind of it. They saw that the proposal did not go through the proper process and did not the competitive bidding process, a fair and equitable process and did not support the the proposal.
Did the Herald know that this is already now the third, you know, the I mean the second or third time around? I'm conf I'm so my mind's boggling already. How many times you guys gone for the process?
They understood that,
but they really didn't like the the non-competitive bidding process. Correct. Nobody likes people. Of course, that's not fair.
Those are the deals that you feel are being done in the back room. That's what happens. Like, hey, why is there no
shenanigans? This is the little shenanigans.
Now, heading into the environment, a lot of people are concerned about the environment and how it's going to affect the environment, you know. Can you elaborate a little bit more on that? Is there effect? I mean I assume if this panel of independent environmentalists approve this and move forward I would assume there's not a precaution taken but I don't know so can you can you
these are the experts that they hired let me touch let me touch on the environment so first of all s is a steward of the environment we have there's a program in the state of Florida that's promulgated by the Florida department of environmental protection called the clean marina program so you have to go through a series of demonstration of best practices and get certified as a clean marina. We have 21 marinas in the state of Florida. 20 of them are certified clean uh clean marinas and one which we just acquired is now pending. So it's the only reason it's not it's just not yet approved because there's there's a process in order to get certified. One of the only major marinas in all of Miami in down in the downtown area that's a a largescale marina that's not a clean marina is the Rick andbacher Marina.
Oh wow. They're not certified.
They're not certified. And Miami Beach Marina, Hullover Marina, and this marina are all certified clean marinas because we are stewards of the environment. The the
Why is Why is that? Why are they're not certified? Have
I'm a Yeah, I'm going to tell you. So, in order to certify, you have to implement certain environmental controls. And there's a checklist of things that you're supposed to do in order to gain certification. That marina is polluting the the bay on a constant basis because what happens is it has no storm water protections. So when you have oil or gas or pollutants that fall onto asphalt or other or cement when a rain event happens if you don't have storm water capture or storm water treatment those pollutants run into the bay.
David very important because is that you of your opinion or that's something that that's known that's is I mean does the city know this? It's one of the reasons why they can't right now or haven't taken the measures to get and we're getting an engineering report to basically confirm saying
yeah because I mean it's crazy.
Another thing that's important to understand a lot of people out there are saying you know you know we want to save Virginia Key in the sense that they want no development.
The city requires a development there. They put an RFP out. Whether it's you guys or it's somebody else it's going to happen.
Correct. Yeah,
correct. And we all bid on it.
Yeah,
we we all bid on this program
and and the the real the real shame is the people of Miami are the ones being hurt by the delay in this process.
Yeah.
You know, this asset and what's happened in the last 40 years on these waterfront assets, it's, you know, public asset uh access, people coming to the waterfront, having that access, not just boers, not you rent slip and you get, you know, you can come and keep your boat there. There there's it's a whole living environment that that gets sustained.
One of my favorite things that I think I saw in the plans that I know you're doing is you're going to connect Miami Marine Stadium all the way to Rickenbacher.
Yeah.
That's amazing.
Down the waterfalling beautiful Baywalk like we've done in Miami Beach and other places.
Yeah. That's going to be
and it's so important because the Miami Ring Stadium, you know, everybody loved the Miami Stadium and everybody passed, you know, voted to to let's get that Miami Ring Stadium back to where it was, you know, get it get it functioning. needs to be, you know, but we have we have one person that's making a lot of money right now on the back of the people of Miami and they don't want this to go forward. So, that's where you're seeing a lot of this misinformation coming from because this was something the city of Miami wanted. You know, the the funny comical part is this tenant is suing the city of Miami right now.
Oh, wow.
We're in litigation.
For what?
Oh, for the grants, the ballot language. They lost on that. They've lost on every time they try to do it. and their whole tactic is delay so they can stay in place.
Well, you know what? What at the end of the day, I I know I keep on beating on this, but it's a it comes down to the taxpayers. It comes down to the residents, those people out there that they're the ones that own it.
Manny, if you look at it, what's happened over just the course of this period of time from the bid to to today, the city of Miami and the people have probably lost 15 to20 million. that is
talking about that. So people are saying
it wasn't a good deal back then for the city and they said it's still not a good deal now. Can you go into the details of what the city will actually benefit? Again,
I think you guys are a little bit crazy. You guys are taking this on. You're dumping in $80 million, you know, to hopefully see some return at some point. You don't own the property. I don't know. That's a business I would like to get into, but go into the details of the benefits for the city. Yeah. So, SUNTEX has over a 100 marinas. We have 75 marinas that have some type of public lease on it. So, we're we probably, you know, are one of the largest whether it's municipal or state payers for leases in the country. Um the the the structure of the Rickenbacher Marina when it went to RFP was a was a structure that was designed to last 75 years. So there's percentage rent involved. So as inflation occurs, as different things happen, as rates go up, they're capturing as a basically partnership with us, they're capturing the the payment of those rents. So it's it's designed to withstand time. That's true.
And six or seven years or eight years from when that occurred,
it is a small portion of the 75 year duration for which that lease structure was designed to withstand. So we had the city demanded we we didn't do it. The city did demanded two independent leases. Um, sorry. The city demanded two independent appraisals as part of the process and both of them which stated we are at or above current market rate and
which and to go further down this line because we're constantly litigation with with the person that's there Milwani. He in a previous deposition said $1.7 million. Now we're paying $2.2 million base. He's paying a total of 1.7 to 1.8 made today is fair market value in a deposition. We have it on the record.
That's crazy.
But he wants to tell us and spread out the information that where it's a 2017 deal. It's old. No, that's not the case. This is all for
because his deal is from like 1970 or 1983 1983. [clears throat]
198. So he has a 1983 deal, right?
And he's saying that the 2007 deal is not good.
2017 deal is right.
Can I can I ask a stupid question?
Absolutely. Um, how long has that been operated by this person?
Since 1983.
Okay. Has any like, you know, new stuff happened in that place?
No.
No. So then now all of a sudden now we're saying, "Oh, now we're going to do this."
Yeah.
So, you know, I mean,
some people have told me that like is there like oil or something that we don't know about? [laughter]
So, so he so he might have made some improvements, some small upgrades, I believe. I don't know. I haven't he might I think he made some investment in the in the fuel dock. But the reason that one of the main reasons at least that the RFP came around was cuz he failed to comply with his obligations to to create uh public parking. And when he failed under his lease terms, the city sued him. In fact, he's been in three lawsuits with the city. Um that's his landlord. his landlord, which Sunex, we don't I don't believe we've ever been in a litigation with our landlord um on on 100 marinas and he's got one
and he's suing the city today.
He's in three lawsuits and he's another lawsuit. But the the the thing is that since it was built so so long ago, which is why this this renovation is necessary. Yeah. is because back in 1983 there weren't the same environmental standards that exist today. And by redeveloping the marina, we're going to bring it up to current code, current resiliency, current current clean marina status.
I hope you're going to clean all that stuff that you said that there's, you know, Oh, yeah.
So, we're we're going to bring the marina up to a clean marina status, which requires investment. investment which he hasn't made to bring it to a clean marina status, but that requires creating storm water capture and filtration and doing a lot of things to protect harmful pollutants from making their way from the marina.
Don't we have the city and the county that regulate that and go out there and check all that area out?
Durm, right? You know what I'm saying? doesn't really aggressive,
you know,
but but it's it's it's built the marina was built so long ago that there's no requirement that he bring it up to code unless he makes a certain amount of in uh investment into the property. I think there's like a 50% rule, but don't quote me on that. But so unless you do a major renovation, you don't have to bring it up to current code. However, in many cases when we acquire marina, regardless, we still try to bring and have brought every marina up to a clean marina standard.
Very important. Another question that I see in the comments a lot.
Are you guys out of state private equity bros?
No. No.
Bobby, tell them your history here in Miami.
Yeah. Been here since the 80s. Worked on the art deco bill buildings in Miami Beach. um went to University of Miami.
I Monty put Monty's in 2004, redeveloped it. I've been here for a long time, continue to be here. You look at my my driver's license. It's Florida. So, I'm not out of state. I'm definitely not a private equity bro. I can promise you that. We're we're a family, small family, father, two sons, business. We've been here in Miami investing for the last 35 years.
Yeah. And a lot of the investors you guys were saying are from South Florida.
Yeah. Correct. for as well too.
So there you go. Not private equity bros coming in to take over the city.
Yeah. And so it's sunte. So I'm the chief development officer. I live in Miami. I've been here for over 30 years. My wife was born here. My kids went to school here or still go to school here. So our family lives here. We employ over a hundred people um throughout Florida throughout throughout this uh Miami Dade County. Um they all live here. Um we we've kept every employee that's wanted to stay with us primarily. Um you know, so we're all local. Yeah. Um and we support more local families than the Rick and Bucker.
Man, you know, I want to ask you a question cuz I haven't been on that side of the coin yet in my life. Right.
How does it feel like that you guys put all this work into this and you see all this information out there and like, you know, painting you in this picture that you just want to like destroy this city, you You know, I just want to get like personal feelings like
personal feelings.
Well, they say some crap about us, too, right?
But you know, please I feel awful. I mean, cuz at the end of the day, the true the true loser are the people of Miami. The constituents, they're losing they're not only money, they're losing an asset,
their asset that should be upgraded. And you have a person who's standing in the way of that. And and all we've tried to do is is is offer the best product and services for the people as well as money and rent. Yeah.
For the people
while doing it in the right way, fair and square.
And we're spending a lot of money in litigation and time and design and things like that. That that's unfortunate because the people of Miami are the ones that are truly losing.
And can I add something to that? I I'm going to go a little bit further. I think the people the taxpayer of Miami has been disrespected. They have been they actually not once twice you know I can you know do my whole Lo Richie song three times a lady here but at the end of the day they've been disrespected in the sense of saying we can take this out to you and you said no there has to be a bidding process. You want it and they still didn't like it and people have been disrespected and say we don't care what they say.
Yeah. we'll just go take it back to the commission. Let's go ahead and do something else. And I like the first time, let's find, oh, we don't like the water thing or the Marines or the biology later. Maybe they want to ask the dolphins or somebody in the water. Well, don't ask the dolphins. They're doing horrible. But anyway, at the end of the day, you know,
the Miami Dolphins,
the Miami Dolphins, you know, all of a sudden now saying we're there,
if I'm a I'm not a City of Miami resident. I live in the county, but if I'm a city of Miami resident that I'm paying for that, I'm being disrespected because you're asking me to go and vote for something and every time I'm telling you how to do it, then you find a way of saying, "Nope, we're going to go around and we're going to do it this." And they've done it how many times?
Three times.
Three times. So, are we going to see now finally if this does go out to vote?
It's going out to vote. Yeah.
And then people say, "Okay, I mean, I don't know anymore. I don't know what happens now. What about it now?" In Miami says, "Yeah, I love it. Go. Let's move forward." They got a beautiful place.
So once that's a good point. Once the city goes November 3rd, they vote yes.
Yes.
There's no more shenanigans.
No more.
Well, that we know of.
Yeah. There there might be. But let me let me let me let me complement something that you said and and you're right.
Um if you look at this process or this project objectively, we've won at every phase. We won at an independent selection committee.
Correct.
Okay. When they threw out our bids, it went then to an independent court system. The court looked at it and felt found that the city acted arbitrary and capriccious, which is basically saying they didn't act in good faith. There was
a judge.
Wow.
A judge ordered a rid of mandamus ordering the commission. And by the way, this is extremely rare because um city commissions are are extended great difference in allow being able to take certain actions unless they believe there's foul play. So the court, an independent court said that there there was foul play and we are now demanding that you, the city of Miami, award the lease to Virginia Key LLC. And then there was questions about there's been questions about the fair market value of the rent. The city of Miami hired an independent two two independent appraisal companies to to analyze the fair market value and both of those found that were at or above fair market rent. I can tell you on the SUNTX portfolio because we pay more rent than almost anyone in the state of Florida to municipalities and state jurisdictions. This will be the most rent we pay to any municipality.
Oh wow.
In the entire state of Florida,
which I'm assuming is higher than what they're being paid now.
Oh, more than almost 2 million a year.
What? Tell me that again.
Almost 2 million. Almost 2 million a year. Over what they're paying over the current people.
Yeah. That's why Bobby's referenced before that over the last, you know, 7 to 10 years, the city of Miami has not received the benefit of the independent process. And over the life of the lease, uh, the proformas that were created as part of the RFP process show that the total payments over the life of the lease to the city of Miami is almost a billion dollars.
Listen, this is I have a personal question to ask you, man. you know, so first RFP you win. Second RFP you win, you know, um they try to do a no bid, they lose, you're here eight years later, you go through litigation, you're dumping all this money, time, effort, energy. Winning RFPs is extremely difficult. You hired one of the best architectural companies, Architectonica. You know, I know that's not cheap. You got to be doing this at this point for principal because did you ever think about I'm just throwing a towel like this is just there's no way.
No. Yeah, you would just want to do this.
You can't You can't let the bad guys win. You can't You cannot let the bad guys win. And that's what you're seeing here. You're seeing they don't like the result of the process that they created, so we'll do it again. Okay. Now, okay, my guys lost twice. We're going to try to do no process. And the people of Miami saw right through that and said, "No." It's one of the first deals that got ever turned down.
Has this Have you guys felt other deals around the state or in Miami? Have you had this type of scenario happen before or no? Is this common?
No.
Can I sing my song? Welcome to Miami.
Because you don't typically have someone that's weaponizing the court system fighting you.
Gotcha. And he and he's using the people of Miami's money that he's making off their asset to sue the city, to sue them, to waste their money, the taxpayers dollars, and his litigation. Up and down.
Yeah. Yeah.
Well, listen. I'm just I'm just I'm just going to tell you right now before we go any further. I just saw a person just come in here right now and and and before we're going to take a little quick break, but I just this this this is this is for me is this is this is this is out of this is crazy. Wait till you see the person that just walked in here. We're going to show you the person come back. We'll be right back. Well, listen. Look who just joined us right now in the day. This this is spectacular. I mean, this is uh I mean, for me, it's a it's a special moment because I I look up to this person. I've I've dealt with this person for so many years. And this is a staple. This is a Miami legend, Mr. Monty Trainer. Welcome to this table talking a day in Miami, sir.
Thank you. Thanks for having me.
No, this is great. Monty, talk to me. What what what's what's what's Monty Trainer been doing apart from, you know, everything else that we that we hear around there? You're you're you're all over Miami. You you've never retired, have you? Well, I don't I don't plan to retire. I listen, this is great. You guys are preserving the legacy that we started years ago. Started in 1969. So, this is nice to see it continue and this is how it goes. So, I feel really fortunate being part of this. Uh, so I'm looking forward to moving forward with SUNTC because they're great operators and they've done a fantastic job with the marina after that storm and everything. They they put a lot of effort in there and it is beautiful. It's one of the prettiest marinas around. So,
Monty, why don't why don't we why don't we take people a little bit down memory lane really quick. How was it with that storm here?
Tell tell people how
which storm
with with with with um with
Hurricane Andrew.
With Andrew. Yeah.
Came across the uh tip end of Kiscane.
Yeah.
And uh everything was blown our our restaurant uh this Life magazine did the center page of all the all the uh everything up on the highway.
Yes. and the everything was down. There was only two or three palm frrons missing, but all the equipment was floating.
Sure. [laughter] So, so it was quite a storm. But uh from here south all the way down to Naranga and my brother was uh in the bathtub with a mattress over.
So, he survived. But in incredible how this how this just stayed how how how it was, you know, and I always talk about and we talk about every time I see you and we've spoken here now in in in the podcast, everybody has a great story about being at Monty's. Everybody has such a great memory of of of time that they spent here. I I mean I I spent a lot of happy hours here, you know. Uh I don't want to tell you how I left the place, but I I I you know, we we we did a great time. Could you, and I know you mentioned this, but and I want Bobby and David to also talk about this, your relationship with Sunday, you said of how great they preserved the marina. How important was that to you when they were doing this? that that ensures that the legacy is going to be preserved because they're quality operators and they've uh they're involved here to make it a quality and then to continue the u legacy that we've got going that we've had going with all the chicken huts and all everything they have planned you know moving forward. I mean, uh, you you take for instance where these boats are. Yeah. There was a travel lift and all the boats were picked up there, taken into that building. So, I mean, there they've improved things so so much here and it's nice. It's nice to be involved with it. But, you know what? There's so many things and I was talking before of what's going on here. This is the first Kors east of the Mississippi.
Wow. and the uh the distributor pors they had the plane flying over the Dolphin Stadium on Sunday and they had me and I was not to disclose what's going on. So anyway, uh I took the distributor and I had a I was part of that plane to get Kors at Monty's and all. So we had this is where he kicked off forever. Everybody used to go skiing.
Yeah. come back with a six-ack of corors.
Oh man, what
this is Pete Kors came down.
Yeah.
And uh we had a thing about
a month about six months ago where Pete Kors came down and we kind of celebrated the initial so much history.
Yeah. So, so we're we're we're honored to have Monty here where we feel blessed. We're we have done a tremendous amount of things to to preserve his legacy.
Yes. Yes. In addition to that, in order to make make sure that this restaurant remains affordable for all, we've kept the vast majority of the items on our menu at $20 or le or less, which is not easy in today's times. And we you can come here with your family and eat affordably. We want everyone to be able to come and experience the water so that it's open to the public for everybody,
right? You know, Bobby, what what has been your experience here with Monty?
Well, amazing. Amazing. I mean, Monty's a legend in the community, in the city. Um, we were fortunate enough to also open a Monty's at the Miami Beach Marina as well.
Yes, that's another place. Yeah.
But this is this is ground zero. Staple. This is ground zero. When I went to University of Miami, the idea that one day I'd come back here and be able to be part of it was awesome.
That's a beautiful story, by the way. The fact that you and the family and David, everybody has preserves what what what what Monty started here.
Yeah.
And also on the beach.
On the beach as well.
And so we have a track record. Yeah. Just just like any other restaurant. We're not coming in to change. We're coming in to upgrade, create opportunity, revitalize, more access for people to uh enjoy the waterfront.
Correct. So
you know, you're sitting right now. This whole area, the championship here, 1983, this is where the hurricane club was formed. This is where it all got started. And it's uh there from there we had the Golden Cane Club. But
this whole every every game week, Monty's was here on the radio, did the podcast, everything. And the same people are doing the podcast now. The the
No. So much great history. I mean, when you saw the Monty's RV,
it's it's me being in Monty's, it's preserved me so well. [laughter]
The Monty's RV parked in the uh in the end zone having the you know,
brother, every football game again when the Dolphins were the Dolphins, you know, but you know, you would come over here and and you could, you know, you would see everything that you know, the best games you I mean, again, it was the best part. You would go out on the boat, everybody get back, and the first thing you come back is to have lunch, have your drinks here. You know what I'm saying? Nobody want you know, boating and drinking. So, we'll park the boat over here and and and and continue. Monte, you that have been part of the Virginia initiative for such a long time.
How long?
Virginia Key.
With Virginia Key.
Oh, you know, I've been on the Virginia Key board forever and ever.
Yeah.
I've been a member. We're not We're not invol as involved as you are now in the SUNTC, but always before because I used to have Jimmy Buffett play here and go over there.
You imagine? What? Damn.
We have a lot of legacy with the Virginia Key.
Just a little name dropping.
None of the name dropping. I don't
No. No. Come on. Come on. Having Jimmy Buffett here. How important is to have a company like this in in in Virginia Key?
Oh, it's fantastic. It makes it makes it worthwhile. Makes it going to happen because that with this background with their background in the marina business and the waterfront. See, I go to all these meetings with the with our committees and I always preach the waterfront and they want to do the things in the grove and this I say this is a waterfront community.
Yes.
And this is what's what they SUNTC brings to it. They are true waterfront. They do nothing but great marinas. I don't know how many marinas they have, but they have a a ton of it. And it's they're quality operators and it's going to ensure that Virginia Key works. cuz everybody else said that. But they'll make it work.
Yeah.
Cuz they make everything work. So, I'm looking forward to it and I hope they embrace me and let me uh let me tell them who worked over there and who who was singing and listen where my boat was.
That that for me and I don't know how that cannot be the best winning combination that you guys can have. You know what I'm saying? the fact of like you know the the voters have taken this again not once not twice but three times you guys have been awarded this I don't know how many times it keeps on going but the fact of knowing that if you guys are there and going to have somebody like Monty you know what I'm saying and and and and Monty say hey we got to get this guy to come and play the guitar over here
and Monty knows where it came from and what it was
absolutely absolutely
and what it can be and I think it's that vision and someone like Monty who can really
see it all coming together and where it should be.
Yeah. Well,
and and with Monty's blessing and which we believe we have,
there'll be a Monty's and Virginia key.
Oh, that would be great.
WOW.
THAT IS That is a That's a great one, David. I love that one. I love that one. Look, I get goosebumps now. We got that one. We got the one Virginia Key.
So, it'll be Gramps and Monty's.
That'll be Gramps and Monty's. I love it. I love it. So, you're hearing here. We're saying it right here. So when everybody here, it will be a Grams and Monty's. That's right. That'll be That'll be like the the the perfect combination. That'll be the That That's like the mega That's like the Mega Millions.
That's wonderful.
That's wonderful. That's great. David, listen, Monty. Um I I know we can't get into like, you know, those uh those stories. But I always say my best times that I had when I was in the commission was coming and going during Christmas in your beautiful boat.
Oh boy. Yeah. You know what I'm saying? We would go cruising out the Bay Area. You know what I'm saying? I'm not going to say who was in the boat, you know what I'm saying? But everybody was good. You know, legal people, all great people, all nice people.
David, every on that boat, MissUSA, Miss our all our beauty contest,
Universe as well.
Miss Universe cuz I cheered three.
You chaired it? Yeah. Yeah. We
So that was nice. all these mission. We took them all the way up the river far as we could go and we did that with every one of the contests that came down here. It was fantastic and all the commissioners loved to take them up there and showboat them. As a matter of fact, that's how on the boat is how we got Bayfront parked. Look at that.
I took my boat and parked it up in Washington DC for two weeks and Rosario Kennedy and myself, we
shout out to Rosario. Love Rosario. Love Rosario.
But anyway, we had the all the commission, all the congressmen, Claude Pepper number one, would come there every day and we'd take little tours up the river. Nobody nobody had seen Mount Vernon.
Yeah.
They go True. None of them. So all of them we every we every day we did a tour. So we we came back with $5 million and used that to buy Bayon Park.
Oh wow.
What a story.
What a great story. You see, you guys thought we were going to get these great history stories here. You know what I'm saying? I think we're looking maybe I'm looking into a sense of maybe doing like um could we do like one of those little booths where Monty can talk like people can go inside and you know and listen to like the history. You know what I'm saying? I mean I think that'd be great.
We can make that happen.
This guy is a legend.
I mean listen he he's got more history. More
got the best person behind that cables. She's got cables in the car. She's ready to go.
SHE SAVED THE podcast today. the [laughter] the stories, the history, the legend. Yes, sir.
That Monty Trainer is what he brings to Miami. He's the heart and soul. There's there's no better partner with SUNTX that we could ever dream for as part of the Miami legacy.
I love that. I love that. I love that.
David, when we first started Monty's, it was a gas station out front, a marine gas station, and they had gas pumps out. So I was out there middle of the night chipping away at those gas pump and the people you know around the neighbors they said this guy's what's he doing at night chipping. So we got rid of the gas pumps and made me and there were seven different locations of of vendors doing business on the property. And so one by one I was able to take them out. I went to Alabama muscle shows and I worked with the landlord and he gave me a lease, 20-year lease, and that's how we all started going right down to the water. That was my goal. Harry Bua, we do what I'm what we were planning to do on a napkin and we stayed true to the napkin. And a lot of restaurant people will do that. They'll tell you the story of how they got started and it's always something like a napkin or something bogus.
But imagine those are the best stories as well that how you started a restaurant on a napkin.
Oh yeah.
And your idea in a napkin.
Amazing.
You know, I mean I wish
you don't still have that napkin, do you, Monty? [laughter]
I would love to see that napkin. I would love to see that napkin. Listen, what a what a what what a treat. Uh Monty, you being here has really just uh it's like the icing of the cake, sir. You know, we really appreciate you you you coming and and and speaking to our audience in in in a day in Miami and the fact of explaining, you know, the what's going on and the whole Virginia key issue. And I I I I think it's it's it's great. And I I want to emphasize once again, we can go ahead and you can go ahead and think and think and say and say, "I don't understand what the situation here is." People went, it was an RFP. You want it. City didn't like it that you want it. They threw it out. They said, "We need more experts." They hired the experts. They brought it back with the same model you did. They voted again. you want it. They still didn't like it again. They threw it out again. They had to go now a judge. They went to the voters and said the voters, oh, let's not do a bidding process. Let's just keep this as it is. Like if the city, you know, you can't do that. You can't do that to the residents. You
They continued, David, on extending the lease that I had already had.
Yeah.
That I got in. I got a I went to the voters and I got it when they
you always go to the voters
and the public
city commission and know the mayor Pere was the he wanted to bring he
number one number one
I didn't my mentor
I didn't win the RFP
but anyway he said listen I understand that has got a plan so we had a thing a story we made a whole thing on a board and I had about 10 people rolled it in to the city commission and there they rescended the vote that they had made on the winners.
Yeah.
And gave me the vote based upon the the presentation and it was a 50-year lease.
So,
but they took it to the voters.
Yeah.
They took it to the voters. That's a great thing.
Miami recommended it.
There you go.
Which of their grin, but
they they voted it in.
Perfect. I mean, that's that's how it should be. Take it out to the voters. The voters voted. The voters here voted that there should be a bidding process and it was done.
Vote and they vote and you and that's it. It's it's it's I don't understand. I don't I don't I don't know why you guys are complicating this. The ones that are like, you know, really want to complicate. I don't know how you can go ahead and attest to something that's been taken out three times already in the sense of and it's been, you know, bidded on fair process one. So again, you know, and and the great thing about it is now we take it back to the borders again. So hopefully this time now
the third time's the charm.
Third time.
You know what I'm saying? That hopefully now when people go Yes. again
and and people want to go see that,
you know, that whole Virginia Key being again at Gramps and Amanti Trainers will be such a great place that now we can do new memories in that place. Gentlemen, I appreciate it. Thank you so much for coming on again and and and clarifying and give you another explanation. Monty, it's always such a pleasure having you on a podcast. I'm thinking that we just got to dedicate maybe two hours to you.
Oh, that's
in the sense of like, you know, let's take down, you know, listen,
I've got a I've got about we've got about 10 scrapbooks already doing.
I I I I don't know what we're waiting for. I mean, I I think I think we should just do a day in Miami with Monty's scrapbooks.
You know what I'm saying? That would that would be amazing.
When you talk about the chorus bit, when you talk about the University of Miami Hurricanes,
everything you talk about everything.
I'm serious.
Everything.
We got to do that. We got to do that.
All the celebrities, all the different all the history, all just the the commissioners, the mayors, everyone that he's been associated with over time.
This this restaurant's been here since 1969.
Yeah.
I there's I don't know of another restaurant in the city of Miami that's been here since 1969. I was born in ' 68. I would have crawled over here. But you know, [laughter] this the city of Miami had banned outdoor dining and I used the Jimmy's hurricane format on how I could do an outdoor restaurant in in the co coconut grove and I took the because they would form the food inside, bring it outside on roller skates. So I figured out a way to serve food at the raw bar. We're using the same concept. So the city of Miami fought me on it and I beat them on it and then I beat them on the village in but it was always rescended. People did not the commissioners did not want food served in inside. So we we we rescended that and got it so that outdoor dining was permissed and so that's it. Outdoor dining started then heaven. I'm tell that's why it's a tremendous podcast in the sense of everything you can say how even outdoor outdoor dining started in Miami here in the growth for the little guy
started at Monty's
started at Monty's. All right guys so we will do another one. We will we're going to I'm telling you right now Monty we got to
pencil in your busy calendar when we're going to do that scrapbook and we're going to do just love to be involved.
We're going to we're going to do that. We're going to do that.
I mean it's exciting what they're planning to do here. I can't believe the uh what they're going to do. how what a what an extensive renovation they're going to be doing that people in Miami are just going to love cuz I think it's fantastic.
Well, stay tuned and like we always say when we end, go out and live it, love it, and make it another day in Miami. Thank you guys. Thank you.
No te pierdas un episodio
Suscríbete y recibe cada episodio en tu plataforma favorita.
Suscribirte en SpotifyMás Episodios
Ver todos
46:22
This Israeli Entrepreneur Saves Miami Developers Millions on Insurance
nov. 18, 2026
1:07:52
The Attorney Saving Miami Businesses From Expensive Mistakes
nov. 17, 2026
56:27
What Miami Could Learn From Denmark | Jesper Møller Sørensen
nov. 16, 2026
1:04:23
How Bizzy Is Changing the Way Miami Students Save Money & Go Out | Evangelos Milionis
nov. 16, 2026